Pieter Wisse
It’s such a familiar term, information management. Are we still making the
concept productive? Do we gain new benefits, and so on? It turns out that
nowadays IM is too little of an information and too much of a management
discipline. Does Information Management: Setting the
Scene (Elsevier, 2007) edited by Ard Huizing and Erik De Vries succeed
in (re)setting the scene?
It certainly does a good job avoiding the technology bias. That is important
for regaining balance. I’m less convinced, though, about the scene being
widened beyond strictly business. Sure enough, most authors of the collected
papers demonstrate an awareness of organizations operating in, and partly
constituting, the information society. A business bias, however, remains
dominant throughout the book. Therefore I find that Information Management,
rather than Setting the Scene, is primarily directed at rewriting the
particular role for IM within the business organization. There’s nothing wrong
with that, on the contrary, but when managing expectations it better be clear.
Seen from this somewhat more limited business perspective, all twenty four
chapters written mainly by academics make perfect sense. For example, it accounts
for calling Maes’ framework from his introductory chapter an “integrative
perspective.” It integrates, so the speak, a single organization’s
informational aspects from strategy to operations, from business processes to
information technology. And, which is the subject of part V with four chapters,
what purpose does IM serve if not supporting customer focus? But then, as part
II with three chapters suggests, IM needs to reorient itself at their
subjective meanings including variety, too.
The chapters are varied, covering what nevertheless remains a lot of ground.
You should read, even study, this book when your outlook is indeed firmly
grounded in business (and not expecting to change that perspective soon). Even
when I personally am not all that happy about it, the majority of the target
audience of “information practitioners, academic researchers and higher
education teachers” should qualify. Be prepared there’ll be much in the book
that you may at first sight be unfamiliar with, that you won’t agree with,
etcetera. Please feel inspired, give it your own shot at design ideas, for that
is the whole point of the exercise. Why bother with innovation when you’re
happy with how your information management, whatever you take it to be, is
going? To benefit, you need to be sufficiently worried to appreciate a sketch
for a changed role. How does business information management perform on the
wider scene of the information society? Meanwhile, society’s scope of
information management needs also being addressed. There’s hope for the book
I’ve reviewed here is just volume 1 of a projected series on “perspectives on
information management.”
Also posted as a review at Amazon.
March 9th, 2008, web edition 2008 © Pieter Wisse